I’ve grown to accept the Touch Bar (and definitely appreciate having Touch ID attached), and scrubbing through video with it is cool, but I still prefer the dedicated function keys. And right now, I don’t feel that there’s enough developer support to make it a must-have (except for the fact that to get the latest CPU, you need to get a MacBook Pro with one). The OLED Touch Bar on top of the keyboard is only as strong as its developer support. I never once had an issue with a gesture, like swiping between Spaces with four fingers, pinching out with five fingers to reveal the desktop, or two-finger scrolling. Instead, it uses haptic feedback to simulate the feeling that you’re pushing down. The 5.2 x 3.2-inch touchpad is spacious, and like models going back several years now, doesn’t actually click. Leaked documents and a patent from March suggest this membrane could block dirt and dust from getting into the keyboard, but no one has said anything about it officially. But iFixIt’s teardown of the machine revealed a silicone membrane around the switches.

What we don’t know for sure is if the keyboard is more reliable than the ones on models dating back to 2015 and for which Apple now has a replacement program.

The clicking is more muted than on last year’s model, though you can still hear it if you type hard enough. The only thing that has changed, according to Apple, is that it’s quieter, and that seems about right. While I’m OK with the keyboard, Apple faithfuls on the internet, tech enthusiasts, as well as some of my colleagues have vocally disagreed with me for the past few years.

Mac pro 2018 review